User Login

User name

Password



Forgotten your password?
No account yet? Create one! You' be able to participate in our forums, submit weblinks, launch information and other fun stuff!

Newsdesk RSS Feed

RSS 2.0
Home / Newsdesk / Industry News / Tripoli 'M' altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Tripoli 'M' altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload Print E-mail PDF
2008 Archived News by AeroTech Consumer Aerospace   
Tuesday, July 01, 2008

ImageCEDAR CITY, Utah USA — On June 20th, 2008 at the Mudroc launch in Nevada's Black Rock Desert, Curt von Delius (TRA 10592) established a pending 'M'-class single motor altitude record of over 40,000 feet AGL using a Kosdon by AeroTech™ (KBA™) Animal-Compatible™ M1450W rocket motor reload kit.

The flight was Curt's Level 3 project and is the culmination of a three year endeavor. The maximum velocity achieved was 2,818 ft/sec (1,921 mph). The rocket was recovered 11.3 miles downrange after a six hour search, and the airframe and fin leading edges showed signs of extreme heating.

The new record shatters the previous record of 35,300 feet set by Jim Wilkerson on 9/17/05. Curt is also the holder of the 'J'-class record of 19,240 feet using an AeroTech J570W motor and the 'L'-class record of 31,316 feet. In fact, seven of the nine existing single-motor altitude records have been established using AeroTech motors.

The entire airframe was constructed with lightweight carbon fiber composites.  The main body was built using aerospace grade, filament wound carbon fiber tube by Composite Solutions, courtesy of Greg Fannin. High density carbon plate fins were attached with Cotronics high temperature epoxy and vacuum-bagged 10.9 oz. aerospace grade Amoco T-650 3K carbon fabric.

The project was launched from a custom-built aluminum tower. Maximum acceleration was 26.2 Gs and apogee occurred at 48 seconds. The vehicle measures 68.4" in length and 3.13" in diameter and weighs 76 oz. without motor. Recovery was accomplished by deploying a highly modified SkyAngle 28" drogue at apogee, and a modified SkyAngle 52" main at 2,400', using black powder charges.

The M1450W is an 8,060 newton-second reload kit that generates a peak thrust of 480 pounds, a burn time of 5.46 seconds and fits Animal Motor Works™ (AMW™) 75-7600 motor hardware. Like all KBA Animal-Compatible reloads, the M1450W is an outstanding value and is priced 25% below the cost of AMW reloads of similar size. The M1450W also delivers a higher total impulse than AMW 75-7600 reloads.

Curt would like to thank Ken Biba, Richard Hagen and all the Aeropac "Founding Fathers" for their continuing help and knowledge. Also, thanks go out to Steve Wagner for his help in the recovery effort. Launch photo courtesy Steve Wigfield.

Animal Motor Works™ and AMW™ are trademarks of Animal Motor Works, Inc.

AeroTech Consumer Aerospace is a division of RCS Rocket Motor Components, Inc., Cedar City, UT.


Post 07-01-2008 03:47 PM  #1
Planet News
Newsbot
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 3
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
STORY UPDATE:
Quote:
From: Tom Rouse
Sent: Tuesday, July 01, 2008 12:54 PM
Subject: Re: AeroTech Information Release 7/1/08

Curt's record is denied.

He used an ALTACC flight computer which uses a baro sensor that is capable of only registering accurately to +- 33,000 MSL. It is the Motorola MPX4100A.

Basically .. below 20 kPa - the device will output a small voltage but the data has MUCH more error than signal and hence is completely unreliable even if the software reports an altitude.

His claim of 44,000 AGL at Black Rock puts his MSL altitude at 48,000 feet which is totally inaccurate due to the ability of the sensor limits at 33,000 feet +-.

As TRA's chair person for contests I have cautioned people over the years regarding use of altimeters that are not capable of operating at the altitudes desired.

To my knowledge, there is only one computer that is capable of accurately recording altitudes over 34,000 MSL and that is the G-Wiz. GPS is another means of collecting accurate altitude data and must be recorded in a format that can be reviewed with the application submittals.

Tom Rouse

Planet News is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 04:44 PM  #2
Just Jerry
Freeform rockets advocate
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 1418
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
What I find notable is that for all practical purposes it was flown with "Jerry propellant".

Edit: I might have to revise that comment. A W would clearly be a Gary propellant.
Just Jerry is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 04:50 PM  #3
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Well Jerry inspired or not--it's a killer motor in what must have been a killer flight.

Tom's comment above makes me wonder where one might find a list of approved altimeters, and for what altitudes. The Perfect Flite Hi-alt and a few others claim accuracy (or to be at least functional to altitudes above 33K MSL).
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 04:57 PM  #4
heada
Certifiable
 
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1225
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
The Parrot V2 in it's 100k' form from Featherweight should be accurate above 33k' MSL. According to the website, it could be used to absolute vacuum. I know the V1 of the Parrot was certified for TRA records. I don't know if V2 has been certified or not.
heada is online 
Post 07-01-2008 06:09 PM  #5
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Thanks, I'll check it out. Thats getting pretty rarified--about 1Kpascal IIRC, or about 1/20 of what Tom is talking about where the S/N ratio degrades to unusability with the Moto 4100 sensor. One can almost imagine having to count the molecules banging around that high--wonder if you see quantum effects.
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 06:18 PM  #6
Garoq
In stock
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 116
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
The rocket also used GPS instrumentation which Tom was not aware of. Stay tuned.
Garoq is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 06:25 PM  #7
Garoq
In stock
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 116
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
What I find notable is that for all practical purposes it was flown with "Jerry propellant".

Edit: I might have to revise that comment. A W would clearly be a Gary propellant.



That is correct.
Garoq is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 06:29 PM  #8
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
We will!

GPS seems like the straight shot. No assumptions, accuracy good to a few meters or better, and with the new GPS 3 system, decimeters IIRC. That takes any guesswork out of the eqn.
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 07:12 PM  #9
NiallOswald
Caught the bug again...
 
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 38
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
I have a question. How would a 40k+ record compare to previous single-motor flights on ~8000Ns motors in similar rockets? Off the top of my head, it seems like a big number for that sort of impulse especially for a not especially slow-burning motor. I thought around 25k was typical for a 3" 6500Ns rocket and the multi-stage M record (44k?) was set using a pretty extreme combination of M1315 to minimum diameter K250W.

If 40k+ on a single M can be verified, that's one hell of a good flight and a real achievement.
NiallOswald is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 07:26 PM  #10
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Well thats a very interesting question pending GPS verification. When that KBA load was announced, I ran to my laptop to see what Rocksim suggested the performance limits were (here was an 8000N-s load with significantly lower ave thrust than the AMW's which were always bested in sims by the longer burning but lower impulse moonburners available).

Even from 5000MSL (our launch site, Black Rock is lower), my design (that appears nearly identical to the rocket in the photogragh) could only muster 37K and change. Thats polished AF and a total Cd(min) of about .38 subsonically, and only about .44 or less beyond 1700'/s. The J record of Curt's is even more astounding. Curt has some serious mojo working as I typically assume RS to be a best case scenario and virtually incapable of underestimates. I don't have more sophisticate software to look at the supersonic side unfortunately.
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 08:14 PM  #11
Adrian A
Featherweight Altimeters
 
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 364
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
The Parrot V2 in its 100k' form from Featherweight should be accurate above 33k' MSL. According to the website, it could be used to absolute vacuum. I know the V1 of the Parrot was certified for TRA records. I don't know if V2 has been certified or not.
Reply With Quote



The Parrot altimeter is certified for Tripoli record attempts. The baro measurement chain and calibration methods are identical between the original Parrot and the Parrot V2, so I assume that the certification for the Parrot V1 carries over to the Parrot V2.

The baro sensor for the Parrot is the Freescale MPXM2102 sensor, which has an operational range of 0 to 100 kPa (1 atm to pure vacuum). I use an instrumentation op-amp that scales the voltage so that 1 atm is over 1 V. Then the A/D I use compares the output to a 1V reference or a 2V reference. The 1V reference version maxes out at about 32kft, and the 2V reference version covers the entire sensor range, down to vacuum. The choice of reference is selected before the calibration. I've given some thought to calibrating each unit with both references, but I don't know if I can fit that into the calibration and flight codes yet, so each unit is individually calibrated for its selected altitude range.
Adrian A is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 10:11 PM  #12
Tom Rouse
Rouse-Tech, Inc.
 
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 17
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Denverdoc says Curt had some serious Mojo going! I think he did too. Nice project. Curt is an EXCEPTIONAL craftsman and is liked by everyone. Pure talent.

In regards to this discussion,
remember, all the information that was submitted to me was the ALTACC baro result as determined at the launch site and signed off by the witnesses.
Rumor has it, that there was a GPS onboard that had a readout of 40,000 +- at max altitude. Black Rock is 4,000 feet, so the rockets performance didn't split the waters of the Red Sea. The existing record is 35,300 feet for a M motor, so IF this flight went to 36,000 feet, it barely beat the existing record.

If the flyer and these witnesses knew there was GPS data on board that had a reading of +-40,000 MSL (36,000 AGL) and used the exceptionally high readout of the ALTACC and ignored the GPS, what would you do if you were me? How could a group of people ignore such a discrepancy and without any discovery as to why there was such a discrepancy, merely submit the higher readout and ignore the GPS?


Now, there is a movement to have me accept the missing GPS data almost two weeks later. This data was not substantiated at the launch by people.
I can not accept this in good conscience.

People MUST follow the rules and launch rockets with the proper altimeters and have those results supported AT THE LAUNCH by witnesses.

Curt can easily launch again.
Or, someone can contact the previous record holder and explain this to him and why his record is taken away. Maybe he also has some "missing" GPS data that was not submitted? Hmmmmm...........

Tom

PS- Jerry- Stay out of this. No one wants to hear your rambling negative BS.
Tom Rouse is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 10:42 PM  #13
ddmobley
Administrator
 
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 4553
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
The existing record is 35,300 feet for a M motor, so IF this flight went to 36,000 feet, it barely beat the existing record.

The existing record must be beat by 2%, which is 706 feet for this particular record, a total of 36006 feet minimum verifiable to claim the record.
ddmobley is online 
Post 07-01-2008 11:00 PM  #14
Just Jerry
Freeform rockets advocate
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 1418
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:

PS- Jerry- Stay out of this. No one wants to hear your rambling negative BS.



Especially when I agree with you and your methods.
Just Jerry is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 11:06 PM  #15
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Darrell makes the very important point that 2 percent or better is required and puts the threshold for a record at 36,000. If the GPS read >42K MSL, I can see where a case could be made. But if its 40K and would barely dislodge the existing record, I would be inclined to say no--mostly out of fairness to the existing record holder.

Had the GPS been intended as the primary means of altitude determination before the fact, and the record was submitted along with supporting data re accuracy, and the flight occurred when there was maximal satellite coverage over the Playa, then even a close call at say 36,050 would be good to go. I think 2 weeks after the fact after being called on the issue of altimeter accuracy is not in the spirit of the competition. You have your ducks in a row at the time of submission, end of story.

As noted, Curt has opportunities to fly again, serious mojo, and with his track record will doubtless find a way to make the next one go even higher.
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-01-2008 11:53 PM  #16
Tom Rouse
Rouse-Tech, Inc.
 
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 17
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
A sincere thank you to Jerry for not biting my head off.
A wonderful and unexpected reply.

Yes, we are evolving!!!!
Tom Rouse is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 12:08 AM  #17
H_rocket
Village Idiot
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 706
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
The whole thing leaves me in some sort of awe...

Less than 6' long
3" nominal diameter
Under 6 pounds dry

Heck, I'd load that with a big I and call it a great afternoon

Talk about going for the throat.
H_rocket is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 01:44 AM  #18
JimJarvis50
Certified Level One
 
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 25
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Tom, you have a thankless job, but thanks anywayCurious about your comments regarding high altitude altimeters.* I know that you are aware of the altitude "bug" that affected the g-wiz products for a while.* I hope no existing records were affected by that.What about the Perfectflight HA-45 or the Adept AltS2-50K?* They have been around for a while and would seem to be above the 34K altitude you mentioned, but are you not crediting data from them?Are you accepting flights where gps is the only data source?Jim
JimJarvis50 is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 01:55 AM  #19
Just Jerry
Freeform rockets advocate
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 1418
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
As far as records go, this particular flight seems to have disparate answers from different altitude methodologies. Further, the stated margin of "beat" seems like it might not be met.

The flight sounds very cool indeed.

One cannot go back in time and reanalyze any "hot track" that might have preceeded it. All you can do is move forward and beat it with whatever motors might exist. I might suggest lowering the diameter further, or flying it from an even higher altitude site using the same combination.

Just Jerry
Just Jerry is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 06:14 PM  #20
Sailorbill
Certified Level Two
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 91
 
Thumbs up Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
As far as records go, this particular flight seems to have disparate answers from different altitude methodologies. Further, the stated margin of "beat" seems like it might not be met.

The flight sounds very cool indeed.

One cannot go back in time and reanalyze any "hot track" that might have preceeded it. All you can do is move forward and beat it with whatever motors might exist. I might suggest lowering the diameter further, or flying it from an even higher altitude site using the same combination.

Just Jerry



POINT!
Sailorbill is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 07:01 PM  #21
blackjack2564
Crazy Jim's Gone Bananas
 
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 188
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
I have just started to fool around with high altitude flights. After searching Tripoli's site,looking for altimeter info on record flights, and finding none.....

Could some one enlighten me as to which ones ARE acceptable, for these kinds of accuracy. Or even if others are qualified for lower altitudes.

During the past year I have expanded my altimeter collection with the purchase of Hialt 45's and Missleworks mini's, hoping these would cover 20-30,000ft accurately.
Not that it matters at this point, I can always buy what's needed, but I would like to have approved alts in my inventory.
You could not give me a G-whiz after the 4 I've been through that don't work.

So.........which one's are the golden bullet?
blackjack2564 is online 
Post 07-02-2008 07:27 PM  #22
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
BJ,
My recommendation would be a Parrot. See:
http://www.featherweightaltimeters.com/

There are many out there, most of them very good, but if you're itching to set a record or two, this would be the one-it is certified to an almost incredible 100,000 ', is very small and light, and has the additional advantage of an accelerometer on-board which can be fun all by itself, and is able to turn some nifty tricks such as only stage (or cluster) if above a certain altitude at such and such a time--in other words has a programmable staging defeat, so that if the rocket veers off course or a motor ails to ignite, it limits the damage. Short story--it is fully functioned and the proprietor is very invested in squeezing the most accuracy and performance out of it, sells for a very fair $130.00 Hopefully one of us will do a full review in the not too distant future.
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 07:53 PM  #23
Adrian A
Featherweight Altimeters
 
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 364
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Thanks for the recommendation, Denverdoc.

The price is actually $149.

I haven't had the spare stock to spare for a review, but that should be changing soon.
Adrian A is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 09:08 PM  #24
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
Still a deal.
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 11:08 PM  #25
UncleVanya
If pigs had fins...
 
Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 4071
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
Thanks for the recommendation, Denverdoc.

The price is actually $149.

I haven't had the spare stock to spare for a review, but that should be changing soon.




Oh no... we're gonna have to review the Parrot? Please don't throw me in that briar patch!


DIBBS!!!!
UncleVanya is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 11:37 PM  #26
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible M1450W reload
I thought you were busy with the night rocket...
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 11:40 PM  #27
UncleVanya
If pigs had fins...
 
Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 4071
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
I thought you were busy with the night rocket...



Guilty... but that hasn't arrived.

Honestly I suspect this needs to go to someone other than me with a wider variety of altimeter experience and with more opportunity to fly sooner than later. The only altimeters I personally have owned are a Missileworks RRC2x and an Olsen FCP-M2. Neither of these use accelerometers and neither has any real recording data to speak of. (The Olsen has minimal recording but nothing like the Parrot). I have friends with Adepts, and MAWD's and HiALT's and ARTS - but little experience outside my own altimeter use.

I just wanted to yank some chains and rock the boat...

I plan on buying one when I can anyway!
UncleVanya is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 11:43 PM  #28
ddmobley
Administrator
 
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 4553
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
How did the M altitude thread get turned into my mods grovelling for freebies?
ddmobley is online 
Post 07-02-2008 11:44 PM  #29
UncleVanya
If pigs had fins...
 
Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 4071
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
How did the M altitude thread get turned into my mods grovelling for freebies?



Please sir... some more porridge.

Sign of the economy?
UncleVanya is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 11:52 PM  #30
denverdoc
Hall Monitor
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 3200
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
Quote:
How did the M altitude thread get turned into my mods grovelling for freebies?



You're right, but this would be only a loaner, and being more proximate, I would hate to see RP inconvenience the vendor with having to mail it. The real thread action has since moved to http://www.rocketryplanet....ad.php?p=91150#post91150
denverdoc is offline 
Post 07-02-2008 11:53 PM  #31
ddmobley
Administrator
 
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 4553
 
None Re: Tripoli ’M’ altitude record shattered using Kosdon by AeroTech Animal-Compatible
How generous of you! ROFL!
ddmobley is online 
Registered users can add comments and discuss this article. To participate, please login or register.

<< Previous Article   Next Article >>
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Blogmarks
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Google
  • Newsvine
  • Fark
  • Furl
  • TailRank

Search This Site

Users Currently Online

We have 62 guests and 27 members online.